Carmel, IN vs St. John, IN

Side-by-side comparison of housing, income, commute, safety, and quality of life.

Score Snapshot

No universal winner

Scores summarize the published model. Use the objective metric differences below and your own priorities to choose.

Carmel

74.5

#579 nationally

vs

St. John

72.5

#884 nationally

Carmel leads in average commute (23.5 min vs 32.6 min). St. John leads in median household income ($123,799 vs $121,400). Carmel leads in cost of living index (108 vs 109).

Metric-by-Metric Breakdown

Metric Carmel, IN St. John, IN
WhereAtHome Score 74.5 (#579) 72.5 (#884)
Population 104,776 23,644
Typical Home Value (ZHVI) $580,014 $464,864
Median Household Income $121,400 $123,799
Average Commute 23.5 min 32.6 min
Walk Score 28 N/A
Crime Level Very Low 0.7
School Rating 9 N/A
Cost of Living Index 108 109
Political lean County 2024 presidential margin — context only, not scored R+6.1 D+5.6

Data coverage note: St. John is missing data for 1 metric that Carmel has. Scores with less coverage are penalized — see our methodology.